Talk:Hololive

voice Q
Do real actors supply voices for these, or are they actual digital reproductions like vocaloid? I don't see any actor names listed on the character pages. Tycio (talk) 04:08, 24 June 2021 (UTC)

They are real people, not Vocaloid or other voice banks, and if you don't see actors names is because that is a convention of the VTuber industry with few exceptions you are expected to believe they are their character and not someone else, in most VTuber circles it is even taboo to address their other identity, the VTuber themselves also don't mention it. In this wiki trying to reveal that information gets you banned, so please be aware of that if you are not familiar with this world. Fireburishi 23 June 2021

Holo ID Gen 1 Gen name
I've seen a few streams of a full ID Gen 1 collab tagged with Area 15 (Example), is that the gen name/should it be added like the other listings like HoloMyth, HoloForce, etc? That-Guy977 (talk) 23:54, 10 August 2021 (UTC)


 * "Area 15" is the name of the show they hold every month on the 15th. Is there any example of them tagging their collab like such outside the show? Writetyper (talk) 00:35, 11 August 2021 (UTC)

About Holostars and UPROAR!! oshi mark.
First, from UPROAR's stream https://youtu.be/-BO_HlkRldU They said that their oshi mark for their group is this emoji 🆙, since it is official, it has to be added.

As for Holostars (as a group), I'm not so sure weather it is official or not, since it was used for the longest times, there are fans that are using 🌟 as their oshi mark, this one doesn't seem to be official but it is widely used from Holostars fans.

Is the Media section necessary
Anyway, the page is getting heavier, should we separate it?

We should split Hololive and Holostar into 2 seperate entities
Similar to Nijisanji's, why haven't we done this sooner? User:Parmduck12 00:00 5 Nov 2022 UTC +07:00


 * I dont think we shold separate it. This way it is easier for people to see the full list of members and branches.


 * I believe that the Hololive page encompasses all of hololive Production. This includes both hololive and holostars. MCPopFan (talk) 10:52, 13 January 2023 (UTC)

HoloPro Memebrs Icon update
all UPROAR members got their 3d now, shouldnt we update their icons on the page? rn it still use 2d.


 * Thanks for pointing that out! Usually, picture updates are done by fellow editor Writetyper. These pictures seem to be custom made (background wise), so it wouldn't hurt to ask! MCPopFan (talk) 10:58, 13 January 2023 (UTC)

hololive English -Promise-
Should we reorganize the page for -Promise-? Haram999 (talk)


 * From my understanding -Promise- is the new unit. I understand that Project: HOPE is closed but does that mean that Council is still considered a group? MCPopFan (talk) 08:25, 9 October 2023 (UTC)


 * It's not yet clear whether the Council label is retired. They haven't made any announcement yet to that effect. No doubt the members will clarify it sooner or later when people bring it up in streams. BeardWizard (talk) 08:50, 9 October 2023 (UTC)


 * Without further information, I think -Council- could still be -Council- and also -Promise-, like Fubuki. Haram999 (talk)

-Promise- can include HOPE and Council, but HOPE or Council cannot include -Promise-. Haram999 (talk)


 * An official explanation has been given by this hololive_En tweet:


 * "With the formation of hololive English -Promise-, hololive English -Council- and Project:HOPE will no longer be used in official capacity, but will still be kept as part of the debut histories of the talents."


 * BeardWizard (talk) 18:14, 21 October 2023 (UTC)
 * No, I'm talking about Oklero's design, we can't let Promise be on par with HOPE and Council. Haram999 (talk)

Also, there is something I am wondering about. They chose to remove HOPE but didn't mention Council. But now neither HOPE nor Council will be used as official units? Haram999 (talk)


 * It sounds like Hope and Council should still be listed separately on the wiki page as they are, for historic reasons, followed by Promise. It's not unprecedented to list members multiple times when they appear or appeared in multiple groups; e.g. Fubuki in Gamers. The current way you have Hope, Council and Promise laid out as separate sections seems sensible to me. BeardWizard (talk) 03:52, 22 October 2023 (UTC)